Which Is Right for You?

In person vs online therapy: which one is right for you? For most people, both can work well, and the better fit depends more on your situation than on which format is “stronger” in general.

In person sessions happen face to face in an office; online sessions happen by secure video, with the same therapist and the same approach, just without the drive. Research comparing the two has generally found similar outcomes on average, though comfort with technology, safety, or what simply feels easier to open up in can tip the decision one way or the other.

This article looks at how each format works, what research suggests, and when one may fit better than the other.

In-Person vs Online Therapy: How Each Format Works

In-person sessions at Serenity Psychotherapy Clinic take place at the Meadowvale office in Mississauga: you arrive, sit down with your therapist in a private room, and the session begins.

Online sessions follow the same structure, but instead of an office, you join a video call from wherever you are located in Ontario. Sessions take place on a secure video platform; the link and joining steps arrive with your booking confirmation.

See our online therapy in Ontario page for how it works. Whichever format you choose, you work with the same therapist and the same set of approaches CBT, DBT skills, and mindfulness-based strategies so the therapeutic relationship and the tools used in session stay consistent no matter how you connect.

What Research Suggests

A 2021 meta-analysis pooling multiple studies that compared video-delivered psychotherapy with in-person sessions found that, on average, the two formats produced broadly similar treatment outcomes across the conditions examined (Fernandez et al., 2021).

That is a general research finding across many studies and therapists, not a promise about any one person’s experience   but it is a reasonable starting point if you are trying to decide whether online therapy can be “as good as” sitting in the same room, since the answer, on current evidence, is usually yes for most concerns. Ontario’s regulator for psychotherapists, CRPO, also requires that “all professional standards” apply “whether . practice is electronic, telephonic, in person, or a hybrid thereof” meaning the confidentiality, consent, and quality expectations do not loosen just because a session happens by video.

When In Person May Be Better

Some people find it easier to build an initial sense of trust and read the room, so to speak, when they are physically present with their therapist, particularly in the first few sessions. A quiet, distraction-free office can also help if home does not offer much privacy, or if a shared living space makes video calls awkward or genuinely unsafe to have. Significant safety concerns are generally better addressed in person or through emergency services than through a scheduled video appointment, since a video call cannot provide the same immediate, in-room response. If you are unsure which format suits your specific situation, that is a reasonable thing to raise during the free 30-minute consultation before you book a first full session.

When Online May Be Better

Online sessions often work well for people juggling a packed calendar, an unpredictable commute, or a stretch of life caring for a new baby, working shifts, managing a mobility limitation where getting to and from the Mississauga office week after week simply is not realistic right now. They can also help someone continue with the same therapist after moving, changing jobs, or simply finding travel harder than it used to be, without starting over with someone new. For some people, being in a familiar space at home also makes it easier to relax into the conversation than an unfamiliar office would.

Couples and Families

Online sessions are offered for individual therapy and for family therapy. A family can join the same video call together from one device, or from different locations if that suits their situation better. Couples therapy is offered in person only, at the Meadowvale office, so partners who would like to work together should plan on in-person sessions. Which format suits a family is a conversation to have with your therapist rather than a fixed rule.

Trying Both

You do not have to commit to one format permanently. Some clients start in person and move to online sessions later, or the reverse; others alternate between the two depending on the week — an online session when travel is hard, an in-person one when it works better with their schedule. Because the intake, the therapist, and the underlying approach stay the same either way, switching formats is usually a logistical conversation rather than a clinical one.

When to Reach Out

If you are still weighing in-person vs online therapy, you do not have to decide before your first contact with the clinic. A free 30-minute consultation is a low-pressure way to talk through which format might suit your situation, ask questions about either option, and change your mind later if your circumstances change. Individual sessions are $220 per hour whichever format you choose; see our fees and insurance page for the full list. We directly bill with most insurance providers — please give us a call to inquire about your specific insurance policy. You can book a consultation or a session directly online whenever you are ready.

References

Share this articleEmailFacebookLinkedIn

Related articles

Start with a free 30-minute consultation

Take the first step toward clarity and support. Meet with Ahmad Shihab online or in person at our Meadowvale office with no pressure or obligation.

Free 30-minute consultation
Confidential & no obligation
In person & online across Ontario

Direct online scheduling via Jane App · Instant confirmation